Reviews For resembling a marriage


Name: Felpata_Lupin (Signed) · Date: 22 Oct 2022 06:24 PM · For: finding reasons not to leave

Aww! He feels for her! He wants to protect her! He doesn't want to leave her alone! And... he's sketching her??? It's just too sweet! And yes, they are still working through the old habits, but you can sense the care between them, it's so lovely to see! And the way she says "we" and holds her hand out for him... small gestures, but so cute! And the way he reacts to it is also so cute! <3

This is just so soft and adorable and fluffy and I'm so happy I stopped by this collection, and I'll make sure to come back to it soon! <3

Thank you so much for writing! <3 <3 <3

Snowball hug,

Chiara



Name: Felpata_Lupin (Signed) · Date: 22 Oct 2022 06:03 PM · For: lazy sundays

Hey Catherine! I've been meaning to take a peek at this, so I'm taking advantage of the Halloween event for some flash reviewing... :P

Aww! Alida and Regulus, being flirty and relaxed and playfully teasing and at ease with each other! <3 That's all I've always wanted for them, and seeing it here fills me with joy! Are they going to get something close to this in the main novel? *pleading eyes* But I guess I'll be happy with this for now! <3

Anyway, I just love the image you picture here! It's the perfect atmosphere for the prompt, and your descriptions are always lovely! And, oh my! He pulls the book from between them, wrapping both arms around her. / "You're my hobby." How sweet is that? And then the kiss! It's just too adorable! <3 <3 <3

Lovely first chapter! See you on the next! <3

Snowball hug,

Chiara



Name: RonsGirlFriday (Signed) · Date: 11 Oct 2022 07:45 AM · For: sneaking out

Tag!!

 

This prompt seems so important for them especially, because of the fact that in by blood everything is happening because of responsibility, and that's why they're so miserable. They're not free. But here they are, it's the basis of this entire AU. So like... them sneaking away from a Black family function to just be on their own, AND I love that they're doing the thing they claimed they were sneaking out to avoid (dancing) -- because really, it turns out, things like that can be perfectly wonderful, as long as you're doing them on your own terms!

 

<3 Melanie



Name: RogueSlytherin (Signed) · Date: 05 Oct 2022 12:33 AM · For: tracing a tattoo

SORT OF LIKE REGULUS IN THAT WAY?! These lines are just bangers one after the other <3 <3 <3 And then it all ends with "I do, too." And all I can think of is the marriage they started with - the 'I,dos' they started with - and the ones they're saying now <3 <3 <3 

Such a great collection. I laughed. I cried. I screamed. I blushed. I read for much longer than I should have because I simply couldn't stop reading <3 Exactly what fluff should be. 



Name: RogueSlytherin (Signed) · Date: 05 Oct 2022 12:29 AM · For: recognizing the other's voice in a crowded room

Whatever she says, it's a sweet song that bridges the gaps he tried to burn down. :Slow Clap: I. Can. Not. With some of these lines you write. They're SO GOOD! 

And I just love when you write Regulus. The shyness, the reserve, the guilt, the panic, the way he wants so desperately to connect but is too scared to try it - and then Alida is there to help him. <3 <3 <3 

I feel like I haven't said enough how incredible it is that you've built so much of a world and such complex characters and relationship inside such short chapters. I know you have a novel with these two, but this is a whole other timeline idea and characters because of it and I'm so impressed. So well done each and every chapter. I don't want to read the last one cause I don't want it to end, but I also so very badly want to read the last one cause they're all so good! XD 



Name: RogueSlytherin (Signed) · Date: 05 Oct 2022 12:24 AM · For: sunset

I DIDN'T THINK I COULD SHRIEK LOUDER THAN I DID IN EARLIER CHAPTERS BUT I FULL ON SCARED MY CAT AFTER READING THE END OF THIS SCENE!!!!! REGULUS!!!!! YESSSSSS!!!!! <3 <3 <3 <3 <3 AND SHE WHISTLED AT HIM XD XD XD 

And then Alida is DYING over his confession but just stays calm and collected so he doesn't freakout <3 <3 <3 They are so perfect for each other!!!! 

And again you're just killing it with these lines like the horizon of pleasentness. 

This collection is EVERYTHING.



Name: RogueSlytherin (Signed) · Date: 05 Oct 2022 12:07 AM · For: up against the wall kiss

I NEED AN ELMO FIRE EMOJI!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! DAHHHHHHH!!!!!!! This scene was UN FUEGO! I def perked up seeing which prompt it was and then was wholly invested throughout the entire scene. Hell. Fucking. Yes. Get. It. You Two. 

And the way its starts with the portraits XD Poor Regulus and his house full of opinionated ancestors XD He's gonna say it out loud one day. He's gonna do it. He said it in his mind this time! That's progress! <3 <3 <3 



Name: RogueSlytherin (Signed) · Date: 05 Oct 2022 12:00 AM · For: on a roof

oof. This one hits. like really really hits. These characters are so complex and I just love that. Alida especially is such an interesting and creative original character. I love how you've written her with such strength and yet so much vulnerability throughout both of these stories she's in. Just wonderfully wonderfully done.



Name: RogueSlytherin (Signed) · Date: 04 Oct 2022 11:55 PM · For: falling asleep together

Yup. Screamed at my computer again. 

That she sleeps so soundly because she feels safe?!?!?! Just dropping warm fuzzy lines so casually up in here <3 <3 <3 And the way you write through this with the siege of his world and his nose just above the surface :chef's kiss: 

And on a sidenote because I'm Regulus obsessed - I just love the details you sprinkle in. That he just needs to think. masterful.



Name: RogueSlytherin (Signed) · Date: 04 Oct 2022 11:50 PM · For: trying to learn about the other’s interests

Art boy Regulus has every piece of my heart. <3 <3 <3 Your writing continues to just pull me into this world and into this relationship and peel away the layers of these two. The way you explain Regulus's stoicnes through Alida's eyes is such a cool perspective. 

I love that I'm laughing along with a pairing that has such tragedy attached to them. That you're managed to bring so much fluff and levity to these two without giving up one inch of their histories or personalities. <3 <3 <3 



Name: RogueSlytherin (Signed) · Date: 04 Oct 2022 11:45 PM · For: drunken confessions

Oh I knew I was in for trouble when I read the prompt for this chapter and it did NOT disappoint XD REGULUS!!! BAHHHH The way his mind can't even bring up the word :Elmo fire: But the way her acceptance just washes away all the other bullshit he's had to endure :Heart Eyes: 

I love them. Thank you for writing this collection. It's so fluffy and wholesome and I just love it.



Name: RogueSlytherin (Signed) · Date: 04 Oct 2022 11:41 PM · For: meeting family or friends

WHY ISN'T THIS HOW THINGS ACTUALY END?! Oh my heart just breaks for these two. For what they go through. For the kids they should have been allowed to be. AHHHHH But you capture this after-war emotion so so well. I love how she compares the sisters and then is like -wait. nope. not at all XD 



Name: RogueSlytherin (Signed) · Date: 04 Oct 2022 11:36 PM · For: gettiing lost somewhere

<3 <3 <3 That's it. That's the tweet. These two are so fucking cute. The way they know each other so well now. The good, happy memories they've got together <3 <3 <3 Love Love Love



Name: RogueSlytherin (Signed) · Date: 04 Oct 2022 03:11 AM · For: Teaching each other how to do something

We've really got to find a way to put an elmo fire emoji on these reviews because THIS STORY HAS ME IN ALL THE FEELINGS!!!! BAHHHHH!!!!! Sexy potion making time?! Yes. Please. 

Regulus being so forward in this chapter and I am here for it! Yes. Sir. And I just love how much Alida is into it, but also just can't tear herself away from the potion-making because that is so on brand XD 

And I'm sorry, but a hummingbird wakes in the bottom of her stomach?! That's such a great line. 



Name: RogueSlytherin (Signed) · Date: 04 Oct 2022 03:05 AM · For: stargazing

IT IS TO LATE AT NIGHT FOR ME TO BE SCREAMING OBSCENITIES AT FICTIONAL CHARACTERS! AHHHHHHHHH! Wow this chapter packed a serious fucking punch in such a quick scene (a little scene that matters <3 )

The way he has endless apologies on his lips </3 The way he's carrying all that guilt and struggle with him </3 but being by Alida makes it better - not all okay - but better and that's all we can hope for sometimes. And she thinks to lie, but doesn't. She's honest with him and he's honest with her and she's poking at him about Sirius and he doesn't get angry cause he knows she's right he's just not ready and then he says it's a winter constellation I AM NOT OKAY 

This collection is giving me all the fluff I hoped for in this challenge and from a pair that are not the sugary sweetest and I just love that. I love the tragedy they're helping eachother come back from it's just beautiful.



Name: RogueSlytherin (Signed) · Date: 04 Oct 2022 02:58 AM · For: sneaking out

I'm screaming at my computer again. You did this. And I'm so happy that you did. This collection is all the fluff and all the swoon and all the warm fuzzies and ugh I just needed some of that today. 

I love your approach to this challenge and these prompts with these two. This story still feels like By Blood. The characters are still consistent and true to themselves, they're just able to be more of themselves because ya know, iminent death is looming overhead....

The way her hand goes cold and then warms up when he holds it. The way THEY START SLOW DANCING IN THE GOD DAMN FOREST <3 And there I go. I'm screaming at my computer again. I loved this. I loved this a ton.



Name: RogueSlytherin (Signed) · Date: 04 Oct 2022 02:53 AM · For: finding reasons not to leave

CATTTTTTTTTTTTTT

I.CAN'T. <3 <3 <3 Regulus is the most adorable kind of weird and unsure and hesitent - but certain. AHHH I love that he's so certain. He doesn't know how to express it. He's still figuring out what it looks like - but he knows he feels it and that she knows he's feeling it AND THEN SHE REACHES OUT FOR HIS HAND AND I JUST FUCKING MELTED AHHHHHH!!!!

The way he thinks he's being childish to feel giddy around her and is like - ew no. XD I love him for that. 



Name: RogueSlytherin (Signed) · Date: 04 Oct 2022 02:48 AM · For: lazy sundays

I knew better than to start this collection this late at night. I was like - oh, I'll just read one chapter and then come back tomorrow and keep at it. Nope. I'm hooked. I'm in it. I need more of these two being soft and fluffy and so so cute <3 This chapter was such a great set up to this AU side of things for them (which I will cling to dearly when I get back to reading the full novel).

The way his sharp features turn to honey and he has a reluctant smile :heart eyes: and Alida doesn't mind staring at him :heart eyes: JUST ALL THE HEART EYES!!! AHHHHHH!!!!!



Name: RonsGirlFriday (Signed) · Date: 31 Jul 2022 02:20 AM · For: finding reasons not to leave

omg, the sweetness of how he quickly moves his journal to his other hand so he can hold her hand "before the offer disappears"! Like... idk, it feels like maybe because Regulus is finding it hard to let go of his facade of not caring, he thinks maybe Alida will be the same, she won't allow her hands or eyes to linger because she won't want to show too much vulnerability. But her hand is still there when he reaches out for it, almost kind of surprising to him oir maybe even to them both, that this support can be offered freely and they no longer have to worry about showing their feelings for one another -- but it's still a different dynamic to transition to, after everything that's come before.

 

Him sitting there with her so she won't be alone is <333 

 

<3 Melanie

 

and tag!



Name: prideofprewett (Signed) · Date: 30 Jul 2022 11:09 PM · For: sneaking out

Hiya Catherine! Back to this story for some review tag (unless the gods have other plans!).

 

Anyway, eep! I love the way Alida and Reg are sneaking off in this frantically wild fashion. It totally suits the parts of themselves they try to hide from the rest of the world. So to be this way with one another, is a lovely sort of thing. I am happy in this universe they feel they can be their authentic selves around one another.

 

Slow dancing in a forest after you've been running a long distance, is hella romantic. You're flushed, breathing heavily, and surrounded by nature. There's just something lovely about that in itself. And whether they dance good or bad it doesn't matter because they are dancing and it is together. And THAT is what's truly important.

 

I love all the extra tidbits of info we get in this piece too. Its Evgenia's wedding, they're doing something together that Alida's Mama would not approve of, the ballroom is a front of DEs...even if we don't know everything happening in the larger world, you hint at enough that we can tell this is a very stressful time for them both personally because of family drama and also politically because of the larger world issues at hand.

 

This was a lovely snapshot of a happy marriage and I enjoyed it immensely!

 

<3 Courtney



Name: RonsGirlFriday (Signed) · Date: 30 Jun 2022 11:11 PM · For: lazy sundays

Yessss Reg and Alida fluff! *little hearts in my eyes* I have so many questions. Is this like an AU of by blood, where they still started out they way they do in by blood with an arranged marriage and all the fjhsjdkfa Voldy stuff? And it's like a wonderful fever dream of how they could have been in a different life? Or is it just a total AU where the premise of their marriage isn't the same as in by blood? 

 

The concept of your hobby being one another fits in adorably with the "lazy Sundays" prompt.

 

I also am very interested in more of that book Alida is reading. XD

 

I'll be back! You know the only thing I want in my heart of hearts is for a happy Reg/Alida who can put all the other horrible shit behind them.

 

<3 Melanie



Name: FlamingQuilltips (Signed) · Date: 03 Jun 2022 08:10 PM · For: sneaking out
I'm back for some more Alida and Regulus - this story makes me feel Reg went too soon in Canon. Love that Alida is able to discern Regulus' microexpressions! Awww, love that they snuck out of the wedding to not-dance elsewhere! Did they escape their wedding or someone elses? They've got this quiet romance thread pulling through this story which I love!
~XOXO Ysh


Name: lostinthelightss (Signed) · Date: 03 Jun 2022 12:01 AM · For: Teaching each other how to do something

CAAAAATTTT!!!! I AM SCREAMING AT HOW CUTE THIS IS I LOVE IT SO MUCH!!!! i love that you just allude to what they'll do, idk i feel like that always makes things more fluffy because it's all the emotion and you leave the rest up to imagination and i just love it so much???

 

also damn i need a regulus, can you send one my way? i can't make potions but i can bake and i think those are similar enough so i think it'll work out yeah??

 

anyways i love this whole thing, its so amazing, i cant wait for the next one AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH



Name: lostinthelightss (Signed) · Date: 02 Jun 2022 11:56 PM · For: stargazing

okay i love that shes pushing him about sirius, and also that she acknowledges that this is something she does because it's something he needs from her, i just think that's so sweet, and them just hanging out talking like this is so fluff

 

SHES A LITTLE STAR THAT MATTERS?!?!?!? idk how you manage to make my heart swoon in the best ways every time, but you do and i love it, 10/10 amazing <3



Name: lostinthelightss (Signed) · Date: 02 Jun 2022 11:49 PM · For: sneaking out

im sorry but the visuals on these are just so good, i can just totally see it like a romcom the way he passes her and then turns around and jogs backwards while watching her. and then them dancing together regardless??? ignoring their responsibilities???

 

hey cat, i think you've owed me like ten thousand apologies for their storyline and how you've made me love them even though i know how it ends, and this au is all ten thousand of those wrapped up together with a bow on top, i love it



You must login (register) to review.